A Bronx neighborhood lost the latest round in a legal fight against the city’s Department of Homeless Services for quietly putting a homeless shelter in a new apartment building.
Bronx State Supreme Court Justice Geoffrey D. Wright dismissed a lawsuit against the city agency lodged by the Westchester Square Merchants Association and local residents who wanted to shut down the homeless shelter. The lawsuit argued that the city had skirted the city charter by not notifying the community board about its plans for the shelter, and that other social service facilities already saturated the area.
The judge based his decision on past challenges to the law that questioned whether the city could legally provide and pay for homeless housing in the absence of a concrete lease — as is the situation in the Bronx building where the agency pays a $90 per diem rate for each occupied apartment.
The arrangement drew scorn from community board members, residents and elected officials when the building at 1564 St. Peter’s Avenue debuted as a shelter in late August. They also criticized the lack of notification from the city agency. Read more..












