Nearly every level of the Bronx criminal justice system was racing on Wednesday to deal with the ramifications of an appellate court decision that declared the 2004 merger of the borough’s Criminal Court and Supreme Court unconstitutional.
Lawyers for the State Office of Court Administration filed for a stay of the decision. The Bronx district attorney’s office was working on the appeal of the ruling, which came in a criminal case it prosecuted.
Administrative judges moved quickly to transfer 10,000 misdemeanor cases and 8,000 unindicted felonies from Supreme Court to Criminal Court, where such cases were heard before the merger. In addition, 26 judges who had been working in Supreme Court were reassigned back to Criminal Court.
It all made for a hectic day, said Judge Efrain Alvarado, the top administrative judge for criminal matters in the Bronx. “I think it has gone very well considering there was no notice.”
The cause of all the tumult was a decision by the Appellate Division of State Supreme Court, issued on Tuesday, ruling the merger of the two courts unconstitutional. That threw into question tens of thousands of misdemeanor convictions over the last five years. Read more..












At the beginning of the hearing, Schools Chancellor Joel Klein defended the proposals.